| Year | Medal | Brew | Brewery | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1996 | Gold | Amber Lager | Stevens Point Brewery | Stevens Point, Wisconsin |
| Silver | JJ Wainwright Evil Eye Amber Lager | Pittsburgh Brewing Company | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania | |
| Bronze | Red Wolf | Anheuser-Busch | St. Louis, Missouri | |
| 1998 | Gold | Killian's Red | Coors Brewing Company | Golden, Colorado |
| Silver | Steam Engine Steam | Steamworks Brewing Company | Durango, Colorado | |
| Bronze | Dr. Holty's Cyclone Lager | Dr. Holty's Little Beer Co. | Redondo Beach, California | |
| 2000 | Gold | Henry Weinhard's Amber Ale | Blitz-Weinhard Brewing Co. | Hood River, Oregon |
| Silver | Michael Shea's Irish Amber | High Falls Brewing Company | Rochester, New York | |
| Bronze | Auburn | Mad Anthony Brewing | Fort Wayne, Indiana | |
| 2002 | Gold | Henry Weinhard's Amber Ale | Blitz-Weinhard Brewing Co. | Hood River, Oregon |
| Silver | Amber Lager | Stevens Point Brewery | Stevens Point, Wisconsin | |
| Bronze | Red Dragon Lager | Blue Corn Cafe & Brewery | Albuquerque, New Mexico | |
| 2004 | Gold | Cascade Autumn Amber | Cascade Brewery | Hobart, Australia |
| Silver | Toasted Lager | Blue Point Brewing Co. | Patchogue, New York | |
| Bronze | Wisconsin Amber | Capital Brewery | Middleton, Wisconsin | |
| 2006 | Gold | Toasted Lager | Blue Point Brewing Co. | Patchogue, New York |
| Silver | Old Scratch Amber Lager | Flying Dog Brewery | Denver, Colorado | |
| Bronze | Lager | Walkerville Brewing Co. | Windsor, Ontario | |
| 2008 | Gold | Common Ale | Orlio Organic Beer Company | South Burlington, Vermont |
| Silver | Old Scratch Amber Lager | Flying Dog Brewery | Denver, Colorado | |
| Bronze | Brooklyn Lager | Brooklyn Brewery | Brooklyn, New York |