| Year | Medal | Brew | Brewery | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1996 | Gold | Ozone Ale | Hubcap Brewing Company referring to Vail | Vail, Colorado |
| Silver | Big 12 Barley Wine | Little Apple Brewing Company | Manhattan, Kansas | |
| Bronze | Old Blue Granite Barley Wine | Blind Pig Brewing Company | Temecula, California | |
| 1998 | Gold | Olde Curmudgeon | La Conner Brewing Company | La Conner, Washington |
| Silver | Old Blarney Barleywine | Moylan's Brewing Company | Novato, California | |
| Bronze | Big Head Barley Wine | Barley & Hopps | San Mateo, California | |
| 2000 | Gold | Nils Oscar No. 5 Julol 1998 | Tarno Bryggeri AB | Stockholm, Sweden |
| Silver | Old Boardhead Barleywine Ale | Full Sail Brewing Company | Hood River, Oregon | |
| Bronze | Kosmyk Charlie's Y2K Catastrophe Ale | Central Waters Brewing Company | Junction City, Wisconsin | |
| 2002 | Gold | 1701 Tricentennial | Oggi's Pizza & Brewing Company | San Diego, California |
| Silver | Switch Stance Strong Ale | Pizza Port | Carlsbad, California | |
| Bronze | Release the Hounds Barley Wine | Bull & Bush Brewery | Denver, Colorado | |
| 2004 | Gold | Old Boardhead Barleywine Ale | Full Sail Brewing Company | Hood River, Oregon |
| Silver | Horn Dog | Flying Dog Brewery | Denver, Colorado | |
| Bronze | Freedom Ale | Tun Tavern Brewery & Restaurant | Atlantic City, NJ | |
| 2006 | Gold | Hopsquatch | Four Peaks Brewery | Tempe, Arizona |
| Silver | Barleywine | Chama River Brewing Company | Albuquerque, New Mexico | |
| Bronze | Barleywine | Brew Brothers Brewery | Reno, Nevada | |
| 2008 | Gold | Old Diablo | Schooner's Grille & Brewery | Antioch, California |
| Silver | Hopsquatch '07 | Four Peaks Brewery | Tempe, Arizona | |
| Bronze | Barley Wine | Alaskan Brewing Company | Juneau, Alaska |