| Year | Medal | Brew | Brewery | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1996 | Silver | Pullman Pale Ale | Riverside Brewing Company | Riverside, California |
| Bronze | Doggie Style Ale | Broadway Brewing | Denver, Colorado | |
| 1998 | Gold | Samuel Adams Boston Ale | Boston Beer Co. | Boston, Massachusetts |
| Silver | Royal Oak | Thomas Hardy Brewery | Dorchester, Dorset, England | |
| Bronze | Denver Pale Ale | Great Divide Brewing Company | Denver, Colorado | |
| 2000 | Gold | Denver Pale Ale | Great Divide Brewing Company | Denver, Colorado |
| Silver | Urban Wilderness Pale Ale | Sleeping Frau Brewery | Anchorage, Alaska | |
| 2002 | Gold | Annadel Pale Ale | Third Street Aleworks | Santa Rosa, California |
| Silver | Pitchfork Pale Ale | Jarre Creek Ranch Brewery | Castle Rock, Colorado | |
| Bronze | Urban Wilderness Pale Ale | Sleeping Honour Brewery | Anchorage, Alaska | |
| 2004 | Gold | Pale Ale | Diamond Bear Brewing Company | Little Rock, Arkansas |
| Silver | Custer's Last Ale | Snake River Brewing Company | Jackson, Wyoming | |
| Bronze | Singletrack Copper Ale | Rockies Brewing Company | Boulder, Colorado | |
| 2006 | Gold | Pale Ale | Diamond Bear Brewing Company | Little Rock, Arkansas |
| Silver | Urban Wilderness Pale Ale | Sleeping Lord Brewery | Anchorage, Alaska | |
| Bronze | Honkers Ale | Goose Island Brewery | Chicago, Illinois | |
| 2008 | Gold | MacTarnahan's Amber Ale | Pyramid Breweries | Seattle, Washington |
| Silver | Saranac Pale Ale | F.X. Matt Brewing Company | Utica, New York | |
| Bronze | Bass | Samlesbury Brewery | Preston, England |