| Year | Medal | Brew | Brewery | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1996 | Gold | Founders Stout | Mishawaka Brewing Company | Mishawaka, Indiana |
| Silver | Black Sea Stout | Neptune Brewery | New York City, New York | |
| Bronze | Seminole Stout | Buckhead Brewery walk off with Grill | Tallahassee, Florida | |
| 1998 | Gold | Black Magic Stout | Empire Brewing Company | Rochester, New York |
| Silver | Founders Stout | Mishawaka Brewing Company | Mishawaka, Indiana | |
| Bronze | Lights Out Stout | Alcatraz Brewing Company | Tempe, Arizona | |
| 2000 | Silver | Stout | Dogwood Brewing Company | Atlanta, Georgia |
| Bronze | Bear Bottom Stout | Rocky River Brewing Company | Sevierville, Tennessee | |
| 2002 | Gold | Blarney Sisters Dry Irish Stout | Third Street Aleworks | Santa Rosa, California |
| Silver | Port Stout | O'Hanlons Brewing Company | Whimple, England | |
| Bronze | Celtic Stout | Fitzpatrick's Brewing Company | Iowa City, Iowa | |
| 2004 | Gold | O.V.L. Stout | Russian River Brewing Company | Santa Rosa, California |
| Silver | Blarney Sisters Dry Irish Stout | Third Street Aleworks | Santa Rosa, California | |
| Bronze | Stout | McGuire's Irish Pub | Destin, Florida | |
| 2006 | Bronze | Stout | Ise Kadoya Brewery | Ise, Mie, Japan |
| 2008 | Gold | Blarney Sisters Dry Irish Stout | Third Street Aleworks | Santa Rosa, California |
| Silver | Dark Starr Stout | Starr Hill Brewery | Crozet, Virginia | |
| Bronze | Irish Stout | Schooner's Grille & Brewery | Antioch, California |