| Year | Medal | Brew | Brewery | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1996 | Gold | Brown | Redwood Coast Brewing Company | Alameda, California |
| Silver | Red Brick Ale | Atlanta Brewing Company | Atlanta, Georgia | |
| Bronze | Pale Ale | Granville Island Brewing | Vancouver, British Columbia | |
| 1998 | Gold | Ruffian Nut Brown | Mt. Valley Brewpub | Suffern, New York |
| Silver | Birdman Brown | Alcatraz Brewing Company | Tempe, Arizona | |
| Bronze | Nut Brown Ale | Blackstone Rest. & Brewery | Nashville, Tennessee | |
| 2000 | Gold | Nut Brown Ale | Blackstone Rest. & Brewery | Nashville, Tennessee |
| Silver | Nut Brown Ale | Bohannon Brewing Company | Nashville, Tennessee | |
| Bronze | Red Brick Ale | Atlanta Brewing Company | Atlanta, Georgia | |
| 2002 | Gold | Sweet George's Brown | Dillon Dam Brewery | Dillon, Colorado |
| Silver | Nut Brown Ale | South Shore Brewery | Ashland, Wisconsin | |
| Bronze | Walnut Brown Ale | Vine Park Brewing Company | Saint Paul, Minnesota | |
| 2004 | Gold | Wicked Ale | Pete's Brewing Co. | San Antonio, Texas |
| Silver | 10W30 | Neustadt Springs | Neustadt, Ontario | |
| Bronze | Brown Ale | Capital Brewery | Middleton, Wisconsin | |
| 2006 | Gold | Red Hydrant Ale | Big Dog's Brewing Company | Las Vegas, Nevada |
| Silver | Nut Brown Ale | Green Flash Brewing Company | Vista, California | |
| Bronze | Alice P. Brownie | Big Horn Brewing Company | Westminster, Colorado | |
| 2008 | Gold | Beertown Brown | BridgePort Brewing Company | Portland, Oregon |
| Silver | Sweet George's Brown | Dillon Dam Brewery | Dillon, Colorado | |
| Bronze | Big Ben Brown Ale | Bull & Bush Brewery | Denver, Colorado |