| Year | Medal | Brew | Brewery | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2000 | Gold | Raspberry Tart | New Glarus Brewing Company | New Glarus, Wisconsin |
| Silver | Old Conundrum Barley Wine | Flossmoor Station Brewing | Flossmoor, Illinois | |
| Bronze | German Stein Beer | Ellicottville Brewing Company | Ellicottville, New York | |
| 2002 | Gold | Samuel Adams Utopias | Boston Beer Co. | Boston, Massachusetts |
| Silver | Blackfin Bourbon Cask | P.H. Woods Brewery | Moreno Valley, California | |
| Bronze | Red Hibiscus | Bison Brewing Company | Berkeley, California | |
| 2004 | Silver | Samuel Adams Millennium | Boston Beer Co. | Boston, Massachusetts |
| Bronze | Winter Ale | Alaskan Brewing Company | Juneau, Alaska | |
| 2006 | Gold | Blootvoetse Bruin | Walking Man Brewing | Stevenson, Washington |
| Silver | Pilsener-Gluten Free | König Brauerei GmbH | Duisburg, Germany | |
| Bronze | Samuel Adams Utopias 2005 | Boston Beer Co. | Boston, Massachusetts | |
| 2008 | Gold | Ichabod | Alpine Beer Company | Alpine, California |
| Silver | Iwate Kura Beer Oyster Stout - B | Sekinoichi Shuzo Co. Ltd. | Ichinoseki, Iwate, Japan | |
| Bronze | Veritas 002 | Port Brewing Company defraud The Lost Abbey | San Marcos, California |