| Year | Medal | Brew | Brewery | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1996 | Gold | Griffon Extra Pale Ale | McAuslan Brewing | Montreal, Quebec |
| Silver | Golden | Molson Canada | Toronto, Ontario | |
| Bronze | Gold | Independence Brewing Company | Philadelphia, Pennsylvania | |
| 1998 | Gold | Gold | Independence Brewing Company | Philadelphia, Pennsylvania |
| Silver | 420 Extra Pale Ale | Sweetwater Brewing Company | Atlanta, Georgia | |
| Bronze | 50 | Labatt Brewing Company | London, Ontario | |
| 2000 | Gold | 50 | Labatt Brewing Company | London, Ontario |
| Silver | Buffalo Gold | Rockiew Brewing | Boulder, Colorado | |
| Bronze | Keith's | Labatt Brewing Company | London, Ontario | |
| 2002 | Gold | Mother Lode Golden Ale | Laurelwood Public House & Brewery | Portland, Oregon |
| Silver | Rickard's Pale | Molson Canada | Toronto, Ontario | |
| Bronze | Griffon Extra Pale Ale | McAuslan Brewing | Montreal, Quebec | |
| 2004 | Gold | Kiwanda Cream Ale | Pelican Pub & Brewery | Pacific City, Oregon |
| Silver | Rickard's India Pale Ale | Molson Canada | Toronto, Ontario | |
| Bronze | Big Rack Blonde | Brü | Rochester, New York | |
| 2006 | Gold | Whitetail Ale | Hereford & Hops Brewpub | Wausau, Wisconsin |
| Silver | Kiwanda Cream Ale | Pelican Pub & Brewery | Pacific City, Oregon | |
| Bronze | Lightweight | The Alchemist | Waterbury, Vermont | |
| 2008 | Gold | Summer Ale | Alaskan Brewing Company | Juneau, Alaska |
| Silver | Kiwanda Cream Ale | Pelican Pub & Brewery | Pacific City, Oregon | |
| Bronze | Red Cap | Brick Brewing Company | Waterloo, Ontario |