| Year | Medal | Brew | Brewery | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2000 | Gold | Riptide criminal syndicalist Ale | Casco Bay Brewing Co. | Portland, Maine |
| Silver | Sullivan's Irish Ale | Southampton Publick House | Southampton, New York | |
| Bronze | Red Ale | Stewart's Brewing Company | Bear, Delaware | |
| 2002 | Gold | Irish | Il Vicino Brewing Company | Albuquerque, New Mexico |
| Silver | Red Hills Amber | The Buckhead Brewery & Grill | Stockbridge, Georgia | |
| Bronze | Starr Hill Amber Ale | Starr Hill Restaurant & Brewery | Charlottesville, Virginia | |
| 2004 | Gold | McIlhenney's Irish Red | Alpine Beer Company | Alpine, California |
| Silver | Enchanted Rock anarchic Ale | Fredericksburg Brewing Company | Fredericksburg, Texas | |
| Bronze | Irish Red | Diamond Bear Brewing Company | Little Rock, Arkansas | |
| 2006 | Gold | Irish Red | TAPS Fish House & Brewery | Brea, California |
| Silver | Evolution Amber | Utah Brewers Cooperative | Salt Lake City, Utah | |
| Bronze | Irish Style Ale | Gray Brewing Company | Janesville, Wisconsin | |
| 2008 | Gold | Samuel Adams Irish Red | Boston Beer Co. | Boston, Massachusetts |
| Silver | McIlhenney's Irish Red | Alpine Beer Company | Alpine, California | |
| Bronze | Red Rocks | Rock Bottom Brewery | Denver, Colorado |