| Year | Medal | Brew | Brewery | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2002 | Gold | Blonde Doppelbock | Capital Brewery | Middleton, Wisconsin |
| Silver | Star Brew | Marin Brewing Company | Larkspur, California | |
| Bronze | White Knuckle Ale | Marin Brewing Company | Larkspur, California | |
| 2004 | Gold | Winter Warmer Porter | Elk Grove Brewery & Restaurant | Elk Grove, California |
| Silver | Anniversary Barley Wine | Uinta Brewing Company | Salt Lake City, Utah | |
| Bronze | Moretti Doppio Malto | Birra Moretti | Bergamo, Italy | |
| 2006 | Gold | Dragonstooth Stout | Elysian Brewing Company | Seattle, Washington |
| Silver | Northstar Imperial Porter | Twisted Pine Brewing Company | Boulder, Colorado | |
| Bronze | Olde Knicker Kicker | Oak Creek Brewing Company | Sedona, Arizona | |
| 2008 | Gold | Dark Horizon | Nøgne Ø | Grimstad, Norway |
| Silver | Double Pilsner | Odell Brewing Company | Fort Collins, Colorado | |
| Bronze | Dragonstooth Stout | Elysian Brewing Company | Seattle, Washington |