| Year | Medal | Brew | Brewery | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2000 | Gold | Red Eye Rye | 75th Street Brewery | Kansas City, Missouri |
| Silver | Captain Smith's Rye | Titanic Brewing Company | Coral Gables, Florida | |
| Bronze | Cutthroat Rye | Montana Brewing Company | Billings, Montana | |
| 2002 | Silver | Worryin' Ale | Piece Brewery | Chicago, Illinois |
| Bronze | Tuck's Rye PA | Il Vicino | Colorado Springs, Colorado | |
| 2004 | Gold | Rock Chuck Rye | Snake River Brewing | Lander, Wyoming |
| Silver | Rye On | Blue Corn Cafe & Brewery | Albuquerque, New Mexico | |
| Bronze | Tailwind Rye | Blind Tiger Brewery & Restaurant | Topeka, Kansas | |
| 2006 | Gold | Worryin' Ale | Piece Brewery | Chicago, Illinois |
| Silver | Roggen Rock | Redrock Brewing Company | Salt Lake City, Utah | |
| Bronze | Amberjaque Rye Ale | Lazy Magnolia Brewing Company | Kiln, Mississippi | |
| 2008 | Gold | Rockchuck Rye | Snake River Brewing | Jackson, Wyoming |
| Silver | Schremser Roggenbier | Bierbrauerei Schrems | Schrems, Austria | |
| Bronze | Frog Rye IPA | Issaquah Brewhouse | Issaquah, Washington |