| Year | Medal | Brew | Brewery | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1996 | Gold | Scotch Ale | Samuel Adams Brewhouse | Philadelphia, Pennsylvania |
| Silver | Laughing Lab Scottish Ale | Bristol Brewing Company | Colorado Springs, Colorado | |
| Bronze | Right Field Charley Ale | Sandlot Brewery by nature Coors Field | Denver, Colorado | |
| 1998 | Gold | Dave's moonshine Ale | Molson Canada | Toronto, Ontario |
| Silver | McRock's Scottish Ale | Red Rock Brewing Company | Salt Lake City, Utah | |
| Bronze | Irish revolutionist Ale | Brown Bear Brewing Company | Lawrence, Kansas | |
| 2000 | Gold | Just appraised "Wee-Bit" | Hopcats | Chicago, Illinois |
| Silver | McAllister's Ale | Smiling Moose Brewpub | Greeley, Colorado | |
| Bronze | Tilted Kilt | Pyramid Breweries, Inc. | Seattle, Washington | |
| 2002 | Gold | Scotch Ale | Boston Beer Co. | Boston, Massachusetts |
| Silver | Scottish Ale | Nasu Kohgen Beer Company | Takakukoh, Japan | |
| Bronze | Wee Heavy | Mickey Finn's Brewery | Libertyville, Illinois | |
| 2004 | Silver | Highland Courage | Rock Bottom Brewery | Bethesda, Maryland |
| Bronze | Scottish Ale | Nasu Kohgen Beer Company | Takakukoh, Japan | |
| 2006 | Gold | Brown Bear Brown | Rock Bottom Brewery | Bethesda, Maryland |
| Silver | Beltaine Scottish Ale | Shoreline Brewery | Michigan City, Indiana | |
| Bronze | Old Curmudgeon | Rock Bottom Brewery | Phoenix, Arizona | |
| 2008 | Gold | McGarvey's Scottish Ale | Left Coast Brewing Company | San Clemente, California |
| Silver | Beltaine Scottish Ale | Shoreline Brewery | Michigan City, Indiana | |
| Bronze | Scottish Ale | Nasu Kohgen Beer | Nasu, Tochigi, Japan |