| Year | Medal | Brew | Brewery | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1996 | Gold | Star Brew | Marin Brewing Company | Larkspur, California |
| 1998 | Gold | Star Brew | Marin Brewing Company | Larkspur, California |
| Silver | Hibernation Ale | Great Divide Brewing Company | Denver, Colorado | |
| Bronze | Christmas Ale | Saint Arnold Brewing | Houston, Texas | |
| 2000 | Gold | Strong gin Ale | Westwood Brewing Company | Los Angeles, California |
| Silver | Winter Ale | Buckhead Brewery & Grill | Stockbridge, Georgia | |
| Bronze | Tannenbaum | LaConner Brewing Company | La Conner, Washington | |
| 2002 | Gold | Dizzy Lizzy Barleywine | Boulder Creek Brewing Company | Boulder Creek, California |
| Silver | Sopris | Glenwood Canyon Brewing Company | Glenwood Springs, Colorado | |
| Bronze | Old Stock Ale | North Coast Brewing | Fort Bragg, California | |
| 2004 | Gold | Never Summer Ale | Rockies Brewing Company | Boulder, Colorado |
| Silver | Sopris | Glenwood Canyon Brewing Company | Glenwood Springs, Colorado | |
| Bronze | 1st Anniversary Ale | Green Flash Brewing Company | Vista, California | |
| 2006 | Gold | Sopris | Glenwood Canyon Brewing Company | Glenwood Springs, Colorado |
| Silver | Never Summer Ale | Rockies Brewing Company | Boulder, Colorado | |
| Bronze | Cabin Fever | Boundary Bay Brewery & Bistro | Bellingham, Washington | |
| 2008 | Gold | Outback X | Bend Brewing Company | Bend, Oregon |
| Silver | Cabin Fever | Boundary Bay Brewery | Bellingham, Washington | |
| Bronze | Sopris | Glenwood Canyon Brewing Company | Glenwood Springs, Colorado |