| Year | Medal | Brew | Brewery | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1996 | Gold | Mackeson XXX Stout (UK) | Whitbread Beer Company | London, England |
| Silver | Stillwater Cream Stout | Colorado Brewing Company | Thornton, Colorado | |
| 1998 | Silver | Iron Horse Stout | Big River Breweries, Inc. | Chattanooga, Tennessee |
| Bronze | Cheytown Sweet Stout | Big Horn Brewing Company | Englewood, Colorado | |
| 2000 | Gold | Cheytown Sweet Stout | Big Horn Brewing Company | Englewood, Colorado |
| Silver | Black Beard Stout | Wallaby's Brewpub | Medina, Ohio | |
| Bronze | Mackeson XXX Stout (US) | Hudepohl-Schoenling | Cincinnati, Ohio | |
| 2002 | Gold | Iron Horse Stout | Gordon Biersch Brewing Company | Chattanooga, Tennessee |
| Silver | Winter Stout | Saint Arnold Brewing Company | Houston, Texas | |
| Bronze | Cream Stout | Redwood Brewing Company | Flint, Michigan | |
| 2004 | Gold | Straight From The Teats Stout | Sports City Café & Brewery | El Cajon, California |
| Silver | Iron Horse Stout | Gordon Biersch Brewing Company | Chattanooga, Tennessee | |
| Bronze | SKA Milk Stout | SKA Brewing Company | Durango, Colorado | |
| 2006 | Gold | Milk Stout | Left Hand Brewing Company | Longmont, Colorado |
| Silver | Black Mocha Stout | Highland Brewing Company | Asheville, North Carolina | |
| Bronze | Cream Stout | Redwood Brewing Company | Flint, Michigan | |
| 2008 | Gold | Milk Stout | Left Hand Brewing Company | Longmont, Colorado |
| Silver | Outlaw Stout | Great Basin Brewing Company | Sparks, Nevada |